For more than a week, we’ve been watching (again) Ken Burns’ wonderful documentary series: “Baseball.” It brought back so many memories. With so much social and cultural division and hatred in our country, we need more baseball. At one point in the documentary, a Dominican play says “We’ve never fought a war or had an insurrection during baseball season.” We need to remember battles fought and lives sacrificed to reach this day. It should not be in vain. Let us at the very least, treat each other with respect and fairness.


We meant to see 42 in the movies, but it got away from us. By the time we were ready to see it, it was gone. That turned out to be fine, because I bought the movie and we had a private screening. Time for baseball and history. Not only baseball. Not only history.

The integration of sports is taken so much for granted today, younger generations can’t imagine it being any other way. This is the movie that shows how it happened. It’s a movie about many things. It’s the story of how and why Jackie Robinson became the first non-white player in Major League Baseball. How this was the start of the integration of all professional sports. It was the beginning of modern baseball as well as the first significant move toward integration in the United States since the end of the Civil War and Reconstruction.

That it was our original home town team, the Brooklyn Dodgers who did it makes the story personal for us. Branch Rickey, owner of the Dodgers, decided it was time to make a difference. Because he could, he changed the world. Harrison Ford as Mr. Rickey mumbles. He’s also real, touching, human. He actually made me cry. Harrison Ford is not known for nuanced performances, but he gives one in this movie.

42-logoI commented that Harrison used to be President, not to mention Indiana Jones. Garry pointed out that owning the Dodgers was far more important. I agreed. Because Garry and I agree: there’s nothing more important than baseball. Especially right now.

Chadwick Boseman bears a strong physical resemblance to Jackie Robinson. He doesn’t sound like him, but that’s quibbling. Nicole Beharie is a pretty good likeness of Rachel Isum Robinson. Who, as Garry pointed out, is even today, one fine-looking woman. It was no accident Rickey chose a good-looking couple. He knew what they would be up against and it would be hard enough. Any small advantage they could gain by just being attractive … well, they were going to need it.

It’s impossible for those brought up after the Civil Rights Amendment to understand the intensity of the hatred, anger and rage that bringing a Black man into baseball caused.

It was 1947, the year I was born. The big war in Europe was over and returning Black soldiers were appalled and enraged that fighting for their nation had done nothing to alleviate the oppression of Jim Crow laws. Segregation was not merely as bad as it had been. It was worse.

Moreover, returning Black soldiers made racists throughout America nervous that their position of supremacy was being threatened. They apparently still feel that way, 70 years later.

It would take 17 more years before the civil rights amendment passed and at least two decades more to make it stick. Twenty-five more years to get a Black President into office. Who knows if we will ever stop hating people because are different color. Race — and the judgments we make based on skin color — are so ingrained, so automatic. So very American. More than apple pie or the flag, we the people love to hate. It’s the most universal of all behaviors. Not as we prefer to advertise, our ability to love, but our willingness to hate. Hate is easier, effortless.

Chadwick Boseman not only looks like Jackie Robinson. He has his swing. I assume they taught him the swing, but they did it well and got that gritty baseball “feel” into the movie. Everyone plays their part with authenticity, as those of us old enough to remember the real guys can attest. Maybe that’s the problem with many of the critics: they never saw the real guys, met them, cheered for them. Lived and died with them through the long season of baseball. They don’t remember, but we do.

The cinematography is great, moving smoothly and naturally between wide and close shots to give you the feeling of the game and more. Nice, tight segues. What is even better captured is the intensity of the abuse Robinson was forced to put up with, to swallow without complaint while simultaneously playing at the top of his game. I’d like to see any modern player survive this.

In many ways, Robinson didn’t survive it. He lived through it, but it killed him from the inside. He blasted open the door of the future and it cost him dearly.

jackie_robinson_brooklyn_dodgers_1954-resizedWhy did Rickey do it? There was a strong moral component. Rickey believed it was the right thing to do. The right thing to for baseball. But it was also a sound business decision. There was a huge pool of talent out there in the Negro Leagues. The Dodgers needed all the help they could get. By bringing in first Jackie Robinson while planning to bring up more Black players, Rickey figured he was going to do some serious winning. He was right.

Christopher Meloni, ex of Law and Order: SVU, nails Leo Durocher, the crazy, quirky Brooklyn Dodger’s manager. He actually looks like Durocher.

If you love baseball, see it. Even if you don’t love baseball, see it anyway. See it for the history, to remember how hard the battle for equal rights was, is and will continue to be. How much baseball, the American pastime, has always been at the center of the American experience.

And finally see it because it’s the story of a genuine red-blooded American hero. In every sense of the word.

From Garry Armstrong:

I have to admit I was tearing up in places even though there’s no cryin’ in baseball. Critics aside, this was no pleasant Hollywood fable but a fairly authentic account of Jackie Robinson, the man and the player and the times that swirled around him.

Much of this is first-hand recall for me. I was 5 years old and already a budding baseball fan in Brooklyn in 1947 when the young player wearing number 42 became a household name. I remember all the excitement in my neighborhood. Some of it I understood. Some of it I didn’t. The newspapers and radio were full of the Dodgers and Jackie Robinson and how what they were doing would perhaps cause problems all across the country.

I remember angry things shouted by White people we encountered. I recall some very nice comments offered by White people who frequently said Jackie Robinson was “a credit to your people.”


Jackie Robinson steals home in the 1955 World Series

I followed the Dodgers very closely over the years. I knew their lineup by heart, could emulate their swings and could recite from memory details of their personal lives along with the baseball stuff. In later years, I’d have the good fortune to meet many of the Boys of Summer including Peewee, Campy, Big Newk, Ralphie Branca, Gil Hodges, The Duke (My hero) and Jackie Robinson.

Later, as a reporter, they gave me their own first hand accounts of what it was like – that memorable year of 1947. I would also hear from Red Barber, the legendary sportscaster who called almost all of the games during the ’47 season for the Dodgers. One poignant memory involves a conversation with Campy (Roy Campanella) and Jackie Robinson. I was now a young reporter and a familiar face to many of the aging Dodgers. Campy was always “the diplomat”, pleasant and smiling.

Jackie always seemed angry. I thought he was mad at me sometimes until Campy said he was just “Jackie being Jackie”. The conversation was about how young Black people conduct themselves. Jackie thought many were irresponsible. Campy said they were just kids doing what kids do. Jackie glared at Campy and then smiled at me saying. “You get it, don’t you?” I just nodded.

Sorry I strayed from the movie but it evoked so many, many memories. And, thanks Harrison Ford, for a splendid portrayal of Branch Rickey!

Categories: American history, Garry Armstrong, Movie Review, Racism and Bigotry, Reviews, Sports

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

16 replies

  1. baseball wouldnt be around if it werent for players like jackie robinson to break the color barrier.


  2. From what I remember- having seen it when it was still in theaters- your critique of the film is much better than the film itself. That is not to say I didn’t enjoy the film. But I just felt something was missing. Maybe I needed to get hit over the head a bit more emphatically as to how difficult it really was for Jackie Robinson. Or maybe I just need to watch it again.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I think that possibly, with Garry, knowing the man and having been there for so much of the history, he adds his own subtext and context. I think they softened it up for the white public. The reality was unbelievably brutal. No one should have to go through that … and especially not while performing a difficult task with the world watching. Garry really should write more. I wish I could get him to do it, but he feels after 40 years of 16 hour days and six and seven day weeks … in every kind of horrible tragedy, blizzard, hurricane … with corpses littering the ground (often before the police and other first responders were on the scene), he’s served his time. He has served his time, but I still wish he’d write more. Because he knows so much and I want to hear it all.

      I liked the movie, but living with Garry, I probably added my own subtext too.


      • Please tell Garry there are a lot of people who would love to hear his stories. And writing for himself is not the same as writing when it is your job. I was a film editor for 27 years. A lot of the time spent was in labs color correcting. And I still love doing it. Granted I did not have to deal with dead bodies. But I’m trying to make a point here. His stories should not be lost and I think he might be able to get some pleasure out of writing again. He’s darn good at it from the little I’ve seen.


    • Emilio, I suggest you revisit “42”. I clearly bought first hand and and personal opinion to my viewing of the film. Plus, I had the advantage of hearing from Robinson and some of the other Boys of Summer. The film got a lot of the “little” and subtle things right. I was truly fortunate to meet those legends. Getting “lectured” by Jackie Robinson will always be one of the highlights of my life.


      • Garry, I will definitely give it another try based on your, and Marilyn’s recommendations. I remember Jackie Robinson but my role model- in baseball, at least- was Willie Mays. I even tried catching like him when I played little league. Any stories there? And if he was a terrible person, I don’t want to know.


  3. I am fascinated with how important baseball is in the USA. I have never seen a game not even on TV. American football has moved forward even if soccer still is the most popular. My city Karlstad has won the Swedish league many years in a row.
    If I go to the states once again maybe I should try to get tickets to a baseball game

    Liked by 1 person

    • Baseball, of all the sports we play, has a deep historical connection to Americans. It’s also different from other games. Slower, more mental. Much less violent with long periods during which nothing seems to be happening followed by bursts of action on which the game hinges, One of the really excellent things about the series is how Burns really makes this special connection the center of the series, explaining how baseball has tied us together as a people often when nothing else seems to be able to bridge differences. It really is special.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Ken Burns makes great documentaries. We have his mammoth series on jazz, which we’ve watched many times.In fact you’ve reminded me it’s due for another airing. Also the Civil War series, which for obvious reasons was not comfortable viewing, but as ever, v. informative. We’ll look out for Baseball. Not a sport I know much about, but Graham was an avid player as a boy growing up in Canada.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Oddly, you don’t have to know much or be involved in baseball to appreciate it. Burns does it all with a masters touch, he make you understand and care. Really brilliant guy.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Marilyn is bookmarking Ken Burns’ stuff right now for us to watch on Netflix. We’ve seen a lot of his work, missed a little. Everything he touches is masterful.
      Revisiting the “Baseball” series has been joyous. It includes the “10th inning” addendum which gave us a chance to watch the Red Sox ’04 season that ended decades of angst.
      This is the perfect time to watch or re-visit “Baseball” given the state of our union.
      I await the “11th inning” which hopefully is in production and will include the Cubbies’ World Series victory, ending their 108 year drought. I assume the great Vin Scully will also will be featured as he called it a career after 67 or 68 wonderful years in the broadcast booth. He’ll always be my favorite baseball voice on so many levels.
      The Red Sox just traded for Chris Sale, one of the best pitchers in baseball. We got the news, first hand, from Dan Shaugnessy, one of the best sports writers around — at a holiday party we were attending. I had Dan repeat the news — shouting into my “good” ear. I just grinned!! The news made my day!!!
      I’m 10 years old again and can hardly wait for Spring Training.
      Hope springs eternal.

      Liked by 1 person

Talk to me!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: