My mom was a psychologist, so when she gave personal advice, people tended to listen. On one occasion, she gave a neighbor relationship advice that backfired. Things did not turn out the way either of them expected.

The neighbor was in a passionless marriage. Her husband was emotionally distant and uncommunicative. The wife was taking psychology classes as part of a program to become a psychiatric social worker. This made her particularly dissatisfied with her flat relationship. However, she had two young children and no way of earning money, so she didn’t want to end the marriage.

She confided in my mother about her unhappiness. Mom threw fuel on the fire. Mom encouraged her not to settle for an empty marriage. She told her that she deserved more and could get more in her life and her relationships. Mom told her that if she left the marriage, her husband would have to support her and put her through school. She could then have a career, a better relationship and keep her kids in the bargain.

I don’t know how much influence Mom had on the neighbor’s decision to leave her husband. But she did leave and expected a favorable settlement and a rosy future.

I tried to tell my mom that however good her relationship advice was, she was giving the neighbor terrible legal advice. My mom had no idea what she was talking about regarding the state of divorce law at the time. Mom still believed that the law totally favored women. She was sure that women were always awarded custody of the kids and always got good settlements.

But times had changed, and so had divorce law. The neighbor was in for a big surprise. Especially since she couldn’t afford a top-notch lawyer of her own. The neighbor didn’t have a place to live or a means of support. So she lost total custody of the kids to her husband. She didn’t get money to go to school. She barely got enough money to support herself — and that support was only for a short time until she figured out how to make a living on her own.

She ended up living with relatives and getting a dead-end, menial job. The kids didn’t spend much time with her for a while because she had no place for them to stay with her. Her whole world fell apart.

She eventually got a place of her own but I lost touch with her. I know she never got to be a social worker. The kids were never a big part of her life again.

I sometimes wonder if the neighbor had understood the ramifications of leaving her husband, whether she still would have done it. I always thought that if she wanted to leave, she should have waited until she had finished her social work training. Then she would have had a career, an income, a place to live, and would probably have kept her kids. She at least would have gotten joint custody. I know her ex-husband. He’s a nice guy. There was no abuse or unbearable hostility. He was always a good and involved dad. Why was she was in such a rush to leave? She didn’t even take the time to research what Connecticut law would provide for in a divorce.

I worry that my mother filled this woman’s head with unrealistic ideas about her fulfilling and happy future. I regret that I didn’t talk to the woman myself. I’ll never know if I could have changed her future. But I feel guilty for not trying.

6 thoughts on “BAD ADVICE – BY ELLIN CURLEY”

  1. Your mother may have given unfortunate advice, but I have trouble believing anyone would proceed with a divorce without at least checking to make sure the information was accurate. You know — a lawyer? Even a counselor?


    1. This neighbor was not the brightest bulb. I don’t know who else she talked to, but she did leave and did get the legal book thrown at her. So she obviously didn’t talk to the right people. I also don’t know how much actual influence my mom had on her. I just know they talked often for a while and my mom was definately encouraging her to ‘do better’ in her relationships. She may have just been telling the neighbor what she wanted to hear and confirming what she wanted to do in the first place.


  2. I’m with Marilyn. Your mom gave the advice, the woman was under no obligation to take it. She should have been better prepared. On the other hand, that was very brave of her. Short sighted, but brave. If a marriage has gone south for whatever reason and a person sticks around trying to revive a dead horse (as it were) or for the kids’ sake, they are short changing themselves. It’s not going to get better the longer it’s dragged out and often it gets a lot worse. I’m all for having two parents raise a child, and so, to me? Don’t have children if you’re not absolutely sure of your spouse. And who can be that positive about another person? Sounds like everyone in that scenario of yours lost.


    1. I personally think that the neighbor should have waited until she had gotten her degree and had a means of support before she bravely exited her stagnant marriage. She shot herself in the foot by making herself totally dependant on her ex for support. And that lost her her kids to boot. By the way, the father was a good dad. He remarried a very nice woman and they gave the kids a stable, if not exciting home to grow up in.


  3. She may have been looking for approval rather than advice…it does sound as if she had already made up her mind by that point, and all she needed was a bit of a tug to leave.


Talk to me!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.