I collected dolls for years. Collecting is easy. Restoring is more of a challenge. Before I gave up collecting, I learned to restore my old dolls.

Portrait of an old doll.

Up front, let me say that I’m not crafty. I can’t sew, crochet, knit, or carve. I can’t change the cartridges in my printer. I can write and I can take pictures. I can draw a bit. And I can cook. Otherwise, I’m pretty much a washout as a craftsperson. But I collected dolls for years. If you collect, there are things you need to do yourself because even if you have lots of money, finding someone else to do them is difficult … maybe impossible. I learned because I had no choice.

This is the best work I did. After Ana McGuffey, I pretty much stopped collecting and promptly forgot everything I ever knew. Use it or lose it.

Composition was the material favored by quality dollmakers such as American Character and Madame Alexander before the 1940s when hard injected plastic became the material of choice. The changeover from composition to hard plastic was gradual. Some composition dolls were produced as late as the 1950s, though not many.

Ana McGuffey – 1946 – Mme. Alexander – Doll’s faces are intended to embody the “adorable” factor of real toddlers.

Composition is basically sawdust, glue, varnish, and paint.  It is a very good molding material, but it disintegrates over time. Dampness rots it. Excessive heat will destroy it. Time will have its way with it. Many dolls I love are old composition dolls. Finding these dolls in pristine condition can be impossible. If available, they are costly. Lacking money, I decided to learn to fix them. Old composition dolls in a state of deterioration are not difficult to acquire. If you can repair them yourself, you can get rare dolls for short money … but you will invest many long hours of yourself.

Ana McGuffey 4

Ana McGuffey (of the reader of the same name) was one of Madame Alexander’s most popular character dolls for decades, from the 1910s through the 1940s. Although her face changed with the times, she always had her hair in braids. She wore a pinafore with a floral print dress. Stocking and buttoned shoes.

I finally got a 20″ Ana McGuffey. Half of each foot was rotted away. The paint on her face was chipped and faded and her wig and clothing were gone. She was in pieces and needed restringing.

I replaced her feet by modeling them using a clay-like epoxy material. This stuff is used for modeling all kinds of stuff. It’s difficult to use but forms a very hard, resin-like substance when it dries.

I restrung her, repainted her face — many failed attempts before I got it sort of right. I found a wig that looked like her original, though not the same material.

Her original wig was made of mohair. While you can get mohair wigs for restoring dolls, they are frightfully expensive and not particularly durable. I also don’t like the way they look, so I went with modern polyurethane. I made the dress and pinafore. This is not an area in which I excel, but no one was making clothing for this doll. It was me or no dress. I could easily get dresses that would fit her, but they wouldn’t look like her original clothing. I wanted Ana to look close to her original.

Ana McGuffey – 1948 by Madame Alexander

She also needed a flowery straw hat and I’d gotten pretty good at buying plain hats and decorating them. I found the stocking and shoes that sufficed, though they weren’t quite what I wanted. I haven’t mastered making shoes, but all things considered, I’m proud of this piece of work.

This is Ana McGuffey, Madame Alexander, circa 1930 – 1940. Restored by me.

Author: Marilyn Armstrong

Writer, photography, blogger. Previously, technical writer. I am retired and delighted to be so. May I live long and write frequently.

21 thoughts on “THE RESTORATION OF ANA McGUFFEY – Marilyn Armstrong”

    1. It’s not terribly expensive to do. You need cord (I got it all on ebay — there are “shops” that sell supplies for repairing dolls) and a couple of clamps. Wigs you buy as you need them and they range from very expensive to not bad, but it depends on what you are buying — real hair, mohair, poly. If you are trying to replace a head of hair that isn’t a wig, that’s basically crocheting. It’s just slow. They make little tools for it that look a lot like tiny crochet hooks.


      1. I have had a bit of a go at rerooting Barbie dolls. I can certainly replace a wig. I haven’t yet restrung a doll but it is a skill I can probably learn. What sort of resin did you use for replacing her foot by the way?


    1. Not perfect, but not bad. To do better than that, I would have had to get serious about paint … and that’s a whole other relatively complicated thing. I can string them, fix rotting pieces, do a little bit of painting (but I’m not very good at it). Replace wigs. Wash, iron, and “refresh” VERY old dresses. And that’s pretty much it.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. She looks really good.You should be really proud of her.I hate sewing and knitting. Never had the patience to learn stuff like that but I wouldn’t mind learning how to fix dolls if I could find out how.


    1. Learning wasn’t hard. Everything is online. There are lots of doll collecting sites because doll collection has become quite the thing. The first time I tried it, I was pretty sure it wouldn’t be pretty — and I was right. But I got better over time. And also over time, I collected what I needed to do the job right. Not expensive stuff, but you need elastic cords for small, medium, and large dolls and a few other things. I never learned to deal with eyes. But wigs aren’t hard. It’s just the right size wig and glue. When you collect, it’s not unusual to NOT glue the wigs down because you might change your mind later and want a different wig and getting old glue off is a pain. It isn’t difficult. But there’s a trial and error thing. You try, and then, you see what went wrong and you try again.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Wonderful advice. I was just saying to Vanda last night that I should check out You Tube for videos. They say practice makes perfect. I look around all sorts of junk shops and garage sales for dolls and other collectables since we can’t afford expensive ones either. We want to keep our hobby going.


Talk to me!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.