A TRULY BAD, ROTTEN, AWFUL MOVIE AND STILL, I KEPT WATCHING – GARRY ARMSTRONG

By now, everyone knows I love old movies. I take special delight in the early 1930s stuff where you see stars and character actors while they were very young and just establishing their screen personae. Barbara Stanwyck is a particular favorite. She had “it” from the beginning. A tough woman who could handle macho fellas like Cooper, Cagney, Gable, Bogie, Eddie G, and so on, but she was also deft at comedy, honing her hard edges. She was likeable even when playing the big cons in those Preston Sturges farces.

This is a long lead into watching a real dog of a movie last night. It was my bedtime film, “Ladies They Talk About” (Warner Brother, 1933). It was a pre-code, women-in-prison flick which grabbed onto every cliché with a death grip and never let go. It didn’t miss a single cliché. There was the wrongly convicted “nice” girl, the crusty “Marie Dressler” hard timer, the bull dykes played with gusto, the wily Italians; the crafty Jewish cons and, yes, the Black inmates all singing (off camera) spirituals while on death row.

Ladies They Talk About prison scene

How bad was this movie? It had two directors, 4 or 5 screenwriters, and a suitcase of AD’s. This had to be Stanwyck’s first or second shot at playing the tough dame who sticks by her villainous sidekicks — including the ever-lame Lyle Talbot. A very young Preston Foster is the crusading good guy who carries a torch for Babs even though she “burns” him several times. For example, here’s a scene so bad it would make Max Bialystock cringe. Barbara Stanwyck and two cohorts, all chewing gum and looking fierce, walk in tandem towards Lillian Roth (yes, that Lillian Roth) who is a smarmy 2-faced bitch of an inmate.

The dialogue was utterly cringe-worthy and you have to remember, I normally relish 1930s Warner Brothers prison movies.

I kept asking myself, “Why are you watching this? It’s AWFUL. It’s bottom of the barrel bad.” Yet somehow, I couldn’t turn it off. I believe my mouth was wide open in disbelief. I was transfixed by the awfulness of the movie. Speaking of dogs and adding insult to injury, Duke, our furry prince, was sharing the bed, nestled next to me, smelling like “dumpster dog.”  So as I watched the incredibly lousy movie, Duke unloaded a series of farts that made me think I was trapped in the twilight zone. Sweet Jesus!

I figured the movie would at least give me an appropriate ending with Stanwyck’s bad girl getting what she deserved. Nope because, in the blur of a second Stanwyck and Preston Foster (after Stanwyck tries to kill him) are hugging and kissing with marriage hovering on the horizon. It had to be karma for my adoration of happy endings. I got it. So, all ye old movie mavens? Be warned.

Avoid “Ladies They Talk About.”  Trust me, should you watch it, you’ll be talking about it.



Categories: Anecdote, Black & White, Garry Armstrong, Movie Review, Movies, old movies

Tags: , , , , , , ,

24 replies

  1. One of my teachers used to say that you had to watch everything in order to learn to appreciate good cinema. Watching the bad helped you recognize what was the good made of and appreciate it.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Frank Faye had that reputation.

    Like

  3. I sometimes have an affection for horrible movies with no redeeming qualities

    Liked by 1 person

    • I understand, Beth. This one had no redeeming qualities except the young Stanwyck.
      Even the pre-code scenes of nubile young women were BAD. For a guy, that says a LOT!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. You know I really want to watch this one now, right?! Marie Dressler and Lyle Talbot….such great names from the past. Garry, you wrote a great review. Now to find when this movie will be on TV…. I’ll get back with you. 😉

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Ha, ha:) I won’t watch this one but sure do like Barbara Stanwyck, Garry.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Becky, me too. She’s allowed a few clinkers in her long and prestigious career. One of my favorites is “Remember The Night”. Again, she is the hardboiled dame – won over by love – in a DELIGHTFUL film.
      There is a scene where someone is singing “When You Come To The End Of A Perfect Day” and Stanwyck’s character is clearly moved – without showing the tears. Gets me every time. This is one you SHOULD see.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Hilarious review Garry, I’ll try to avoid this one. How’s your book coming along?
    Leslie

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I have had the good fortune to have missed this one. It sounds like Duke is a born critic.

    Liked by 1 person

Talk to me!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: