A while ago (a few weeks maybe?), I made two chicken pot pies. We ate one for dinner and froze the second one. The other night, Owen was poking around the deep freeze and said, “How about pot pie for dinner?”
“Sounds good to me,” I said.
We didn’t take it out to defrost since it was already cooked. Figured we’d just stick it in the oven and keep cooking it until the thermometer said it was hot enough.
And, that’s what we did. It took just under an hour to heat until it was 150 internally. We took it out, sliced into it.
(Long pause.)
I finally said, “That’s not chicken. That’s apple. This is an apple pie.”


We three stood there looking at it. I remembered we’d made a couple of apple pies at the same time I made the chicken pies. I’d made a lot of crust and needed to use it. We all like apple pie. Now, there was the pie. We were hungry.
“Screw it,” Garry said and took a huge piece of pie. Then we all took a big piece of pie and ate. Fruit is good for you. Vitamin C and plenty of cinnamon, too. The crust is sort of like bread, right? After that, I ate something out of a can. Owen found a bagel. Garry ate the remainder of the pie.
It was the best dinner we’d had in months.
“I think,” Owen said as he finished his last bite of pie, “We need to start marking these containers before we freeze them.” Yep. Definitely. I have to assume we had already eaten the chicken pot pie, though no one could remember exactly when.
There’s no moral to the story except that apple pie isn’t a bad main course. A little caloric, but yummy.
Categories: #Food, #Photography, Anecdote, baking, Humor, lyrics, Music, You Tube
At least nobody would have said “This tastes like chicken.”
LikeLike
😁 That’s actually pretty funny 🙂 No, it really didn’t taste anything like chicken.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, the laughter here…. we all had made that experience, but apple pie instead of chicken, that’s especially funny! But what a great experience; your culinary tastebuds had to quickly rearrange their ‘feelings’! And so yummy!
LikeLike
Garry likes apple pie — a LOT. AND he was hungry, so while Owen and I were trying to figure out what to do about dinner, Garry was digging into the pie. We instantly recognized he had a point, so we did too. It WAS funny. We thought it was funny. At least it was tasty, if not exactly what we had in mind.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Mmm, Apple pot pie! 😉
LikeLike
It was delicious. Owen pointed out he’d eaten cold pizza and beer for breakfast, so why not apple pie for dinner? I’ve had the cold pizza, but skipped the beer. Substitute a cold Coca Cola.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I saw the title, I immediately thought of the Irving Berlin song. He really did have a song for everything.
LikeLike
It hit me that way too. I didn’t actually know it was Berlin, but I knew the song because my mother used to sing it. He wrote a LOT of songs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The sort of dinner you describe is the best kind of dinner. No planning, just al fresco, even if it were a bit of a surprise! Why not have apple pie for dinner? You listed all the benefits to the idea. I think people get locked into a notion that ‘dinner’ (or supper) has to be meat and potatoes and veggies (or variations on a theme). The trips down a side road are the most satisfying in my point of view!
LikeLike
It wasn’t a bad idea. It was just not what we had in mind. Once could not argue with the tastiness and we really WERE hungry.
LikeLike
Ever had apple pie with hot custard poured on top?
That probably doesn’t sound yummy to you. But it’s great.
At least the way Aunty Elsie used to serve it.
LikeLike
We had it in England. That kind of custard isn’t available around here. Actually, they didn’t have it when I lived in New York, either but it really is delicious. Ice cream works too 😀 Extra calcium.
LikeLike
HA! I know how that goes. I’ve gotten better at marking what goes in the freezer. This seems like a good surprise, but chicken pie instead of apple could have been a difficult dessert!
LikeLike
I never thought of that, but yes. Apple pie wasn’t a bad dinner, but chicken pot pie would not have been much of a dessert. A little heavy maybe.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apple pie is welcome any hour of the day.
LikeLike
It was a good one, too. Just a bit of a surprise. I just remember staring at it and thinking “That’s not chicken.” And THEN realizing “Wait — that’s…apple.” It took me a couple of minutes to collect my brain.
LikeLike
Ha! Dessert for dinner sounds good to me! I mark and date everything that goes in my freezer. I’d never remember otherwise.
LikeLike
I think we’ll be doing more marking. I usually can see what’s in the container, but this was in a crust, so…
LikeLike
Apple pie is good for any meal.
LikeLike
Ironic, but it really wasn’t a bad dinner at all. I would have had more pie, but Garry got really serious about it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lol! So you can have a repeat of this menu!
LikeLike
In theory, yes. Practically, that would mean I have to make more pie and be surprise when it arrives. I think we have learned at least to mark items we freeze!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, that always wise. With a date on it too.
LikeLike