FIELD OF BROKEN DREAMS – GARRY ARMSTRONG

Many of you know we recently visited Cooperstown and Baseball’s Hall Of Fame as part of our Silver Anniversary road trip celebration.

The shirt is from our previous trip, 23 years ago.

The shirt is from our previous trip, 23 years ago.

It was the best of times. It was the worst of times.

Celebrating 25 years of marriage still leaves me astonished. These have been the best years of my life and all the credit goes to Marilyn who has seen me through some difficult times while surviving several life and death health crises of her own.

72-Baseball-HOF-new_063

It was Marilyn who had suggested we return to Cooperstown for our anniversary. In a year of many family soap opera crises, Marilyn realized this would be the perfect spot for her husband, the lifelong baseball fan.

72-Babe-Ruth-Baseball-HOF_073

72-Jackie-Robinson-new-Baseball-HOF_036

We entered the Hall of Fame with great expectations. This has been a year of baseball disappointment because of our under-achieving Red Sox. We would forget all the bumbling performance of this year’s team as we visited heroes of the past.

72-Red-Sox-Baseball-HOF-new_027

72-Duke-Snider-Jersey-Baseball-HOF_030

Team loyalty is on hold in the Hall of Fame. You are walking among the greats. These are the heroes of your youth and those who came before them.

72-Women-Baseball-HOF-new_054

An odd little souvenir shop cum wax museum exhibit down the street from the museum.

An odd little souvenir shop cum wax museum exhibit down the street from the museum. Garry with “The Boss.”

But something was wrong. We had trouble seeing the photos and exhibits in many of the rooms. The lighting was very poor. Non-existent in some places. Exhibits were all behind glass, crammed into tiny little locker-sized cabinets.

72-Garry-Baseball-HOF_013

Many of the scenes recalled from our visit 23 years ago were missing. Access to the exhibits was severely limited and most of the interactive stuff has been removed. The intimacy that was so much a part of our earlier visit was gone.

72-Garry-Baseball-HOF_052

There were no benches in exhibit areas. The very limited seating was confined to hallways near the exits and elevators. This created a rather hostile environment for anyone with mobility issues and ignored the needs of the older faithful (the majority of visitors) who had come to recapture memories.

72-Garry-Baseball-HOF-new_074

Restrooms were difficult to find and required a guide. No signs pointing to restrooms or signs for the other exhibits. Which is unfortunate since the museum is labyrinthine. If we hadn’t stumbled on exhibits while trying to find the restrooms (then trying to find our way back), we’d have missed everything.

Is this the latest in museum design?

72-Cardinals-Baseball-HOF-new_045

The final insult was the dreary gift shop. It had been a treasure trove in previous visits, full of unique stuff you could only get at the museum. We still have the shirts we bought there 23 years earlier. This time, it was all the usual stuff.

There’s a better selection at the shop on Yawkey Way across from Fenway Park. Marilyn — who can always find something to buy — couldn’t find anything. Sad.

72-Vignette-Baseball-HOF_010

Last time we were there, a life-size Babe Ruth with Abbot and Costello’s “Who’s On First” playing in a loop, greeted us on arrival. This time, nothing. It was just a museum with bad lighting and no place to sit down.

It seems like baseball’s main attractions had been scaled down. The museum, in an attempt to cram in more stuff, has lost understanding of what fans want to see.

Major league baseball, with billions in its coffers, is forgetting its showcase. Neglecting the fans who visit from around the world. I’m not sure whether or not this is a reflection of baseball’s internal problems. If so, it’s a crying shame.

There were some nice moments. Hanging out with baseball greats in fantasy sessions. Swapping chit-chat about how the game has changed and thanking them for those memories — frozen in time across the decades.

Maybe I should sympathize with the Hall of Fame as I approach the midway mark of the seventh decade of my life.

Then again, maybe not.

Which doesn’t mean if you love baseball, you shouldn’t go. You should go. Because for lovers of baseball and its history, it is the only game in town.

“It’s ain’t over till it’s over.”


R.I.P. – YOGI BERRA

72-Yogi-Baseball-HOF-new_059

Yogi Berra passed away yesterday, September 23, 2015 at the age of 90. His contributions to baseball are too great to even begin to list. He was the last of the living legends.

Yogi, we will always miss you!

72-Wax-Baseball-HOF-new_084



Categories: #American-history, #Photography, Sports

Tags: , , , , , ,

37 replies

  1. Yay, Dodgers and thanks for mentioning Yogi, and for the picture of left-hander Babe Ruth. “a world of innocence” and the crack of the bat. du,du,du,DU,da,DA, charge! Oh, sorry, I love baseball. Thanks for the post.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Glad you liked it. We love baseball too, so it’s always fun writing about it, no matter what.

      Like

    • Thanks, Elva. I am counting down the days of a lost season for our Red Sox. But I’m also looking at the young players who are blooming before our eyes. I also look forward to playoffs and World Series even if our guys aren’t participants. It’s still our national pastime as far as I am concerned.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I SO loved all those pictures! Even though the museum was not quite up to par, loved especially the first picture of Garry looking quite happy! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Garry and baseball is a happy guy. Just being around all that baseball stuff makes him happy, kind of by osmosis.

      Like

    • Rose, despite my complaints, I absolutely LOVED visiting the Hall of Fame. It reminds me of my youth, my baseball heroes of another day and a world of innocence.

      Like

  3. Agreed. Usually that kind of progre$$ has dollar $ign$ on it

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Sadly I see (or hear, I suppose) about this more and more. Look at the Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall of Fame; from the get go it’s been about how much they can put in the doors and not the history or uniqueness of what got the acts today to where they are. :/

    Liked by 1 person

  5. The trouble with museums is the same trouble with teaching history. More history is made everyday, but they don’t give us more room or time to present it. It looks like they need to add some buildings.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Rick, I’m glad I have our earlier visit for a sense of perspective. The Brooklyn Dodgers retro shirt I am wearing was purchased back in our ’92 visit. A chap tried to literally buy it off my back. Speaks to the quality of stuff they are now selling.
      I believe they need to rethink how they’ve dealt with the museum in recent years. They’ve regressed in the name of progress. They’ve lost the intimacy that is so much a part of the Hall of Fame.
      When we visited our old friends in Vermont, I came away with a treasure trove of baseball books.
      The love affair continues.

      Like

  6. You and Marilyn make a great team, Garry. Congratulations to you both.
    Leslie

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I always wanted to go back to visit my favorite museum again, now you have me wondering if it’s still the same. Great pics, great story. As I said yesterday, “I will buy me a baseball book for dummies.”

    Liked by 2 people

  8. It’s always disappointing to revisit a place you enjoyed only to find that it has been modernised and changed beyond recognition. It’s happened to me a couple of times. I can understand the previous comments about preservation. However the other issues like lack of seating, signage and hard to find restrooms are harder to excuse. I thought that museums liked to provide interactive experiences these days so it does make you wonder what they were thinking.

    Liked by 1 person

    • All I could think was that this was some weird museum version of a fashion statement. The complete absence of seating in the exhibit areas combined with lighting so dim a few people were using their cell phones as flashlights?

      Who makes these decisions? I could understand a dimly lit hall if the exhibits were lit, but this was just dark. If it weren’t for having a very fast lens on that camera, there wouldn’t have been any pictures, either. I don’t get it.

      Liked by 1 person

    • I’ll blame the upper management “suits” who ruin everything. Still, it’s the Hall of Fame and our baseball heroes are there to be remembered. Consider this a cautionary tale but don’t let it keep you away. Hey, it’s baseball!! You cannot ruin our game no matter how hard they try.

      Like

      • True, I am sure I’d feel the same way about the cricket museum at Bellerive Oval where I watch cricket in summer. Come to think of it I haven’t been there since they re-furbished it so hope I won’t have a similar experience to you..

        Like

        • I have no idea what the “latest thing” in museum design is. For all I know, this really IS just a bad fashion statement. I’d be curious to find out if it’s an international trend.

          Like

  9. We’ve been there twice, and I noticed the big difference. I’m guessing besides preserving things from being damaged, the average person is looking for a ‘drive through’ experience so they can get back to their technology.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s why Garry says the “powers that be” — whoever they are — have lost touch with their fans, of what people who this particular museum want. For that matter, museums in general.

      People who visit museums are different. If you didn’t want to get up close and personal with history, you wouldn’t be there at all. One would think the designers of museums would “get” that. Apparently not.

      Like

      • We visited one museum in Gettysburg. We learned a lot from reading large billboard type signs. There were no uniforms, shoes, hats, and only one or two weapons. It was reading. 😦

        Like

        • Gettysburg was rather odd. The town is a museum sort of and the battlefields. But it’s very disorganized. I suppose the excuse there is that no one “owns” the whole thing. Each piece is maintained by either some governmental (state or fed) agency, or private donations or just private money, so it’s a patchwork.

          The museum in Cooperstown is not a patchwork. MLB owns and runs it. And they are NOT short of money. Given their location, they could easily add another building to the complex. They aren’t hedged in by buildings or budget. They are out of touch with the people who they are supposedly trying to please … and I suspect it is just another symptom of a malaise in all sports these days.

          Like

    • We (I) are not the average “pink hat” fans. Baseball has been in my DNA for as long as I can remember. You may be right about the average visitor. As a lover of the game, I’ll take this year’s Hall of Fame visit in the same spirit as I do our current Red Sox team.
      Wait til next year!

      Liked by 1 person

  10. I can see part of the reason for the low lighting, and the fabrics behind glass: people want to touch this stuff, and after a few thousand pats and texture touchers, the cloth begins to deteriorate because of the acids and oils in our skin. I volunteer in the state historical society here, and know how much damage can be caused by people (Im a toucher too) wanting to feel the cloth, touch the hem, as it were, of fame.
    Lighting is another issue. Light (as any photographer knows) can destroy a photo over time, and any other substance that is light sensitive, including cloth, books, newsprint, even the finish on furniture. Direct artificial light is nearly as bad as sunlight.

    So I’m reading this with the sense of your disappointment first and foremost, but the more I think about it, the more I suspect they may have decided preservation was more important than hands on experiences.

    Beyond that, Im glad you got to go, one last visit with old memories, and a perfect time to do it. Happy Anniversary, you guys.

    Liked by 1 person

    • They should consider actually finding out what people want. MLB has money coming out of their collective ears. They could make the museum however they want. It’s not like they are in the middle of Manhattan and there’s no room, so they have to make a choice between A or B.

      We weren’t the only people who were disappointed. It was quite the topic of conversation between strangers. One guy tried to buy the shirt Garry was wearing because there wasn’t anything to buy in the shop. There really WASN’T anything to buy in the shop and I am the world’s best consumer. I can always find something to buy … like … anywhere. But not there.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Judy, you may be right about the safety issues. But there’s also the intimacy factor that is so important for genuine baseball fans. I mean no disrespect to the exhibits and artifacts but this isn’t the Louvre.
      As a retired reporter who has covered some of the world’s major museums, I truly respect the need to insure the safety of baseball’s treasures. But this museum is supposed to be fan friendly. I think proper precautions can be taken while retaining the Hall of Fame’s once unique intimacy.

      Liked by 1 person

      • oh I get that.
        I guess its as much about having something left to show the next generation, too. It’s a balance. keep the good stuff back, look but dont touch, and let there be exhibits of maybe second grade (but still the real thing) stuff, maybe a bit worn, less than pristine. Im sure all those ball players had more than one Jersey with their number/ name on it…
        Sounds suspiciously like Big Guys got hold of the museum and have begun presenting it for people who aren’t even sure who Joe DiMaggio was. you know, the newcomers.

        Or, qu’elle horreur, someone walked off with a baseball jersey or a glove, or something not tied down, hoping to make some money. It does happen. Im not defending or arguing, just playing devil’s food advocate here. Trust does have its limits.

        Like

  11. A reflection of modern times I guess. It’s often a disappointment to visit places after many years and find it’s been “modernised”, and not for the better.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Maybe I’m out of touch, but I’ve been to museums just about everywhere. You might say I’m a bit of a museum-aholic. I’ve been to tiny little museums in backwater towns that were better designed. This museum is supported by Major League Baseball. They may be short of brains, but money is not the problem and there was nothing wrong with the museum that properly applied money couldn’t fix.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Progress, as you know, isn’t always a good thing.

      Liked by 3 people